+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=51)
+---- Forum: SHL Arcade (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=56)
+---- Thread: Werewolf Game 9 (/showthread.php?tid=104940)
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Chevy - 03-31-2020
Also, if you want to “seer” me and block me go ahead. I can’t do anything anyway. I am the hunter. I claim the hunter and have been truthful this entire game. And I’ve already used my ability.
I know eventually the wolves will eat me. They have to while there’s still two because the hunter can beat a werewolf 1 on 1.
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Chevy - 03-31-2020
03-31-2020, 06:55 PMDurden Wrote: Yeah, not the intention. Sorry if it came across that way. Bad way of implying incredulity.
Trying to teach why it's a bad thought process, but it's stonewalled. Can't do much other than argue, it seems.
if it is bad thinking, we can discuss it during game over. But I stand by my idea 100% and currently can not be dissuaded
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Durden - 03-31-2020
03-31-2020, 06:59 PMGeekusoid Wrote:03-31-2020, 06:55 PMDurden Wrote: Yeah, not the intention. Sorry if it came across that way. Bad way of implying incredulity.
Trying to teach why it's a bad thought process, but it's stonewalled. Can't do much other than argue, it seems.
if it is bad thinking, we can discuss it during game over. But I stand by my idea 100% and currently can not be dissuaded
I'd love to have more chats. WW has been a ton of fun, and a huge social experiment.
Look at some old games on here and gomhl. Also, town of Salem is great to play to get experience, and those games are quicker.
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - fishy - 03-31-2020
03-31-2020, 06:58 PMGeekusoid Wrote: Also, if you want to “seer” me and block me go ahead. I can’t do anything anyway. I am the hunter. I claim the hunter and have been truthful this entire game. And I’ve already used my ability.
I know eventually the wolves will eat me. They have to while there’s still two because the hunter can beat a werewolf 1 on 1.
If you die tn over a vital role then WWs are uh playing this interesting
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Mook - 03-31-2020
Votes
3 - Tommy (Muted, Durden, Fish)
2 - Muted (Luffy, Geek,
1 - Grum (Dayude)
Keep the game civil, y'all thought I was a villager for an entire game
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Sean - 03-31-2020
03-31-2020, 07:52 PMMook Wrote: Votes
3 - Tommy (Muted, Durden, Fish)
2 - Muted (Luffy, Geek,
1 - Grum (Dayude)
Keep the game civil, y'all thought I was a villager for an entire game
I'll vote Muted don't think it's going to matter though. @Mook
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Samsung virtual assistant - 03-31-2020
Mook is always a werewolf.
Just gotta change a handle on the trailer then drive home so i can read though this, lol
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Durden - 03-31-2020
Sweg, please vote for Tommy so we don't get into a tied scenario.
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Sean - 03-31-2020
03-31-2020, 08:50 PMDurden Wrote: Sweg, please vote for Tommy so we don't get into a tied scenario.
Tie goes against me anyways
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Samsung virtual assistant - 03-31-2020
OK so my thoughts on this mess.
The side against Muted and Durden is putting a lot into one simple line posted by mook
"As soon as the moon breaks the horizon, a howl rings out. This is different than previous ones heard, there is no pain in the tone, just a thunderous, deep gutteral sound."
Saying that it means the Nhamlet was the alpha being killed, and that it was the birth of a new alpha. I would argue that one could read it like the alpha wolf becoming "enraged" or something being the only one left behind. This is of course a wild speculation from my part. I do see the thought behind it being the birth of a new alpha though, so i do get everyones concern. It made me think twice too.
I am however willing to bet my cards on Muted being Seer and Durden being Escort. That over the slim chance that Seer, Escort AND Lookout were killed off that quickly at random. I'm not saying it's impossible though, just super unlikely. I think RED was the lookout, and by the slim chance that all three roles are dead already, i guess he could've been the seer, as he seemed to know my role as Doctor, as he tried to stop Durden from digging more into my role.
I might as well be wrong believing in Durden being Escort however, there is a real possibility, and if the game still isn't finished after Tommy is dead i'll re-value my position. I do however believe that we're on the right track with tnl being turncoat, seeing how quick and very vocal he got after Geek came up with the theory that Durden or Mook, or both combined were the actual wolf/turncoat side. Also jumping on Geeks claim that i was a WW, saying he'd suspected me the most after LukeTD, then also less than 30 min after 3rd night came to an end, voting for me to start the bandwagon which almost got me hung because he smelled blood after Geeks post about me, and still tries to paint me as a target as the idea had already been planted.
Also, where did people get this idea that there are 2 wolfs + TC left? If you put so much trust in Mooks flavor text about the gutteral howl meaning Nhamlet was the alpha being killed, where do you get that there are 2 wolves left? I might just be tired, but i don't see anything pointing at that if we're going by the text.
I believe that Geek and Hockey are both on team village, Geek is paranoid and i don't blame him, it's a game of deceit after all. Why he was so eager to convince people that i was more of a suspect than anyone else because i said i was so sure of Segi being a wolf that i'd bet money on it, i have no clue. Why i would need inside information for making that statement is a little weird. I do however think he is a good guy and tnl took advantage of that.
Tommy initially putting his vote on tnl because "why would a wolf kill the turncoat" just seems like a big misdirection IMO. Wolves doesn't even know for sure who the turncoat is, so that argument doesn't make sense. But i mean, what are the wolf side going to do if people feel like they have them pinned? Of course they'd try to find a way out of it? Anyone would, they're trying to play the game just as much as everyone else.
Am i 100% sure that they are the roles they claim? No.
Do i trust Muted and Durden more than the other side right now with all the coincidences that needed to happen for them to be lying this well? Yes.
Change vote to TommySalami @Mook
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Chevy - 03-31-2020
Welp. 4-2 in favor of Tommy
Let’s nightfall this already and see if I’m as crazy as you would like me to be
@Mook
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Samsung virtual assistant - 03-31-2020
03-31-2020, 10:29 PMGeekusoid Wrote: Welp. 4-2 in favor of Tommy
Let’s nightfall this already and see if I’m as crazy as you would like me to be
@Mook
4-3, Tommy voted for Muted too. Still 2 people who hasn't voted tho.
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Samsung virtual assistant - 03-31-2020
@Grum @hockeyiscool
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - Durden - 03-31-2020
Sweg, you're absolutely right. With.. everything. TNL taking advantage, this being a game, everyone lying. It's spot on, man.
I'm 99% sure it was just flavor text as well. I know when I do these things, I try to make it a story. I try to drop SOME hints, but very rarely. Most of it's just color commentary. I ask people what they want their last words to be, etc.
RE: Werewolf Game 9 - TnlAstatine - 04-01-2020
@Grum @hockeyiscool make a decision which side you wanna be on
the village or wolf side