Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - Printable Version +- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com) +-- Forum: Community (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17) +--- Forum: SHL Discussion (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=49) +---- Forum: Suggestion Box (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=50) +---- Thread: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users (/showthread.php?tid=102056) |
RE: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - RainDelay - 01-02-2020 Except it’s not transparent :( RE: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - hewasajazzman - 01-02-2020 @RainDelay to be honest, and i in no way mean any offense here, ive seen sigs that i believe are more cohesive and technically skilled receive a 2/5 from other graders. i most definitely took that WAY too heavily into account when i was grading your submission and for that i am sorry. i had originally thought to grade yours at 2/5, with some bonuses for the better ones, but felt that those grades would not be on par with some of the others ive seen. i gave the bonuses on top of the 1/5 for all 4 sigs so that they would pay out just under a 2/5 for that reason. i absolutely see the work you did to your submissions, however i did feel like only a small percentage of that work landed in a way that enhanced the sig. as i described in your critique i also felt as if some of that work actually took away from the sigs, like the lens flare on izzy’s neck. ive had a discussion with my other team members and it was sort of agreed upon that whats more important is that the elements are there and that i am more or less here to suggest ways to control those elements. again, thats my bad. right after i graded this submission i took a look at your next submission and noticed some major improvement. please do not give up on graphics as i can see that things are starting to come together for you and you will only get better and better. RE: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - RainDelay - 01-02-2020 01-02-2020, 01:37 PMhewasajazzman Wrote: @RainDelay to be honest, and i in no way mean any offense here, ive seen sigs that i believe are more cohesive and technically skilled receive a 2/5 from other graders. i most definitely took that WAY too heavily into account when i was grading your submission and for that i am sorry. i had originally thought to grade yours at 2/5, with some bonuses for the better ones, but felt that those grades would not be on par with some of the others ive seen. i gave the bonuses on top of the 1/5 for all 4 sigs so that they would pay out just under a 2/5 for that reason. Hey man, thanks for responding! I appreciate the explanation and as you know I meant nothing against YOU or your team I just felt like I was wronged because of what I’m used to getting and the amount of work I put in. I took it to arbitration so that’s that and thanks for noticing my improvement! Even if it just gets bumped up to 2/5 and maybe one 3 id be fine. Thanks for acknowledging that it might’ve been a little low. And don’t worry, I’m definitely not giving up! I do gfx all the time and I plan on making draft sigs for both this league and the NSFL as well! RE: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - slothfacekilla - 01-02-2020 01-02-2020, 01:31 PMRainDelay Wrote: Except it’s not transparent :( Ya it isn't perfect, but can be helpful for quick work RE: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - Merica - 01-02-2020 I got a 4/5 on a sig I made with photoshop mix/express on my phone. So I think the graders are good af. RE: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - Merica - 01-02-2020 01-02-2020, 02:01 AMRainDelay Wrote:01-02-2020, 01:56 AMSimply Incorrect Wrote: Whoever told you those sigs looked good was just being nice, to be completely honest. They are maybe 2/5. Maybe I am a dick, but atleast I’m honest. RE: Stop the Bias Against non-Photoshop Users - RainDelay - 01-02-2020 01-02-2020, 05:30 PMSimply Incorrect Wrote:01-02-2020, 02:01 AMRainDelay Wrote: You could be so many things, but for six, no... seven years now you choose to be a dick. Meh, I’ve met plenty of honest people who aren’t dicks. |