+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Forum: SHL Discussion (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=49)
+--- Thread: Idea to Fix Sim (/showthread.php?tid=122151)
Pages:
1
2
Idea to Fix Sim - caltroit_red_flames - 02-21-2022
Get rid of tactics. Roles are enough.
@WannabeFinn be the hero we need.
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - PremierBromanov - 02-21-2022
If we dont have access to tactics, that just inherently makes some roles better than others. No matter what configuration of tactics we choose to be the default, some roles will perform better always
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - Wally - 02-21-2022
Simon T! Simon T! Simon T!
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - Henrik - 02-21-2022
Just get this over and done with and make the switch to Blades of Steel
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - Wally - 02-21-2022
02-21-2022, 01:03 PMThatguy91 Wrote: Just get this over and done with and make the switch to Blades of Steel
On board. Definitely on board!
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - Bfine - 02-21-2022
I dont think full tactic removal is the correct option, but I would like to see limit on what can be done at the player and line level tactically because I think thats where a lot of the knowledge gap can occur.
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - Skeleton Party - 02-21-2022
02-21-2022, 01:03 PMThatguy91 Wrote: Just get this over and done with and make the switch to Blades of Steelim putting all my tpe into the spaceship minigame on the jumbo
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - boom - 02-21-2022
no player tactics when
But yes, I agree with what Bfine has said.
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - Sean - 02-21-2022
We really need some kind of build limitation. These meta strategies don't work when you use them in the regular game because the players don't have the exact same build. It's unrealstic that you're whole team is made up of a "power forward" type player.
I believe having a good selection of archytypes and a limitation of how many you can have on one team would be very effective in fixing the current problem.
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - caltroit_red_flames - 02-21-2022
02-21-2022, 02:01 PMTommySalami Wrote: We really need some kind of build limitation. These meta strategies don't work when you use them in the regular game because the players don't have the exact same build. It's unrealstic that you're whole team is made up of a "power forward" type player.Based Tommy :prayge:
I believe having a good selection of archytypes and a limitation of how many you can have on one team would be very effective in fixing the current problem.
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - SlashACM - 02-21-2022
Not even a knowledge gap, unless you count not knowing how to cheese the sim the knowledge gap
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - BarnabasCollins - 02-21-2022
When there's 5 GM spots open you know this isn't working
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - Chevy - 02-21-2022
Removing tactics will not make the sim better. In fact, it may ultimately make the gameplay worse. I feel the modification in cost for attributes is a first step in the right direction to "normalizing" players and actually making tactics more effective/important than not.
Tactical roles for a player only dictate what that player is supposed to do on the ice within the tactics selected, however in its current iteration with what I call the "Hamilton Meta"....there seems to be a primary focus on 4-5 key, specific skills that when maxed out tend to negate most things.
Its a hot take, but having a cap in the J combined with the new costs for attribute increase, there's more parity there than in the SHL. If the SHL wants to truly have parity and entertainment we need to convert the way WE play to how the game functions...not try to break the game into submission on how we play.
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - wumaduce - 02-21-2022
02-21-2022, 12:47 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote: Get rid of tactics. Roles are enough.
@WannabeFinn be the hero we need.
500 tpe hard cap, fixed retirement dates. Get On My Hockey League.
RE: Idea to Fix Sim - hockeyiscool - 02-21-2022
02-21-2022, 07:36 PMwumaduce Wrote:Hear me out, what about 425 tpe cap but it only lasts 4-5 seasons.02-21-2022, 12:47 PMcaltroit_red_flames Wrote: Get rid of tactics. Roles are enough.
@WannabeFinn be the hero we need.
500 tpe hard cap, fixed retirement dates. Get On My Hockey League.