03-28-2020, 01:24 PMhockeyiscool Wrote: I mean, people wanted to know what some of the "lesser" roles were.  Not sure if that was a bait or not.

Those "people" were mostly me to be honest.

And I still think it's a decent approach, even though it carries some risk of course. So you claim Knight, if no one contests it then we have a good reason to believe you and treat you as a somewhat-confirmed villager. If someone does contest it then that gives us an interesting situation with multiple suspects and more information that we can build on. In the specific case of the Knight you also still have the safety option of the extra life to keep you alive. Now we shouldn't doe these reveals for too many roles because as you or someone else has said, it makes it too easy for the WWs to narrow down the more important roles, but as long as only say 2-3 people do it, we are fine. And we basically already have the Hunter and the Knight, so maybe that's all the role reveals we need for now, but a third one would probably still be fine.