Not that it means much from me, but this is the only way I can explain what's happened:

Muted is a werewolf and they've done a great job because he's the only one that needs to put his neck out.

We basically spelled out the strategy that if we catch the Alpha tonight it's going to be game over for the werewolves. Werewolves can read that too so they decide not to kill tonight. I still don't think Durden is working with them. The werewolves actually have a bunch of information they know there's a doctor and an escort, they know who is claiming to be a vanillager and they know which werewolves are claiming vanillager.

Let's look at this list:

Night one: Segi - Wolf (No one is going to come out and deny this)
Night two: Tron - Vanilla (Claimed to be a vanillager and voila, is one in this list)
Night three: Tnl - Turncoat (Who would come out a say "no actually, I'm the turncoat")
Night four: Fish - Vanilla (Once again vanillager)

Nothing in that list is going to have anyone coming out and denying it.

Geekusoid - Hunter (made the claim, not going to deny it)
hockeyiscool - Knight (basically told everyone he's the knight, not going to deny it)
Durden - Escort (Told everyone he's the escort, not going to deny it)
Jfisherr - vanilla (not going to deny it unless seer, but given gameplay I'm guessing this is a werewolf buddy)
Mutedfaith - Seer (Obv not going to deny it, he made the claim)
TnlAstatine - Turncoat (Probably would deny it if he actually was, yet he's not here to defend himself, odd)
Tommy - Alpha (Well I'm obviously going to deny this)
NotoriousTRON - Vanilla? (Claims to have seen that they are a villager but puts a question mark? also is claimed to be vanillager)

Given the information the werewolves have as long as I'm not the seer they have a pretty good shot at making this plan work. If I am the seer they still have a good chance at making this work because no one is going to believe me. Isn't a little too perfect that you're plan worked out exactly the way it should have @Durden?