03-31-2020, 05:47 PMGeekusoid Wrote:

03-31-2020, 05:37 PMjfisherr Wrote: So, ive had time to think this through.

I have a question for @Geekusoid and @TnlAstatine

This new theory all came about from the introduction of a new alpha right? That raised the alarms that perhaps muted and durden were playing this game too perfectly by claiming the Alpha was Tommy when there was no night kill, which gave them solid alibi and solid credibility to the rest of us villagers, when they are in fact wolves and could easily set Tommy up. That's where this whole theory originates approximately.

So, they've claimed Tommy is the alpha, but as they are TC and wolf, they know Nham is the true alpha. WHY on earth would they vote for Nham, knowing that they'd be killing the alpha and bringing them down to 1, maybe two wolves? Did they think Mook wouldn't let it sneakily be known that the alpha was killed? IF they played the game this smart and played us all, don't you think they'd have realized that based of the written flair Mook had when we killed Segi, that he would've somehow sneakily revealed that there was a new alpha? That's absolutely such a stupid colossal fucking mistake for two people who you two think are playing 7d chess at the moment. There's no way people who have played the game so smart supposedly would be dumb enough to realize that Mook wouldn't introduce a new alpha sneakily.

That's why I'm going back to my original thinking, and that I think they are right. I can't see two people, supposedly smart enough to realize one is wolf and one is TC, being dumb enough to vote and lynch the alpha wolf. It doesn't make sense.

Its a team game though..even if just 1 werewolf lives and all villagers die (turncoat included), they win.  So far, it seems we've been sacrificing villagers left and right (my hunter kill included) and luckily have found 2 werewolves in the process.  Its a martyr play, and I don't think its dumb...I think thats one hell of a play.   NHam even said that "our plan"....so segi was the first, he was the alpha...a new alpha came out last night.  

Durden keeps saying 100% that he blocked tommy and that tommy was the alpha...he still insists it but Nham was the alpha.  How can he block the alpha when the person he was blocking wasn't the alpha?


Right now, the plan they've been pushing for is still going to come to fruition.  Grum still has the majority vote to be lynched.   They can choose not to kill tonight to prove "tommy" was the alpha, despite his pleading from day 1 that he is not a werewolf....which based on last night I am completely inclined to believe at this point.


and as I've kept telling Muted and Durden...if they are correct, villagers win.
If I'm correct though, villagers win.
If I'm correct and muted and durden win...and I die (very soon)...and they keep their impressive persuasion up, WW wins.  Basic math still stands.  We have 2 WW, 7 villagers (including TC).  The TC can eventually be a sacrifice play.

It sounds like a dumb idea to sacrifice the "alpha" as a wolf....but this is the liars game of chess. Just like in actual chess, sometimes you have to sacrifice the queen (alpha) in order to win.

IF you think muted and durden are teamed up as wolf and TC, who do you think is the last WW then?