Login

gordieboom · 03-22-2019, 05:57 AM

Hi, this is Gordie's take on evaluating teams strength. In my eyes a team strength can be calculated by looking at the teams top three lines.
Not every team is playing with four lines so i have skipped that from the equation. Also i have combined the defense lines and forward lines into one instead of calculating them separately.
For me it makes more sense to calculate the whole line that is one the ice (sorry goalies excluded).

What i have simply done is adding all skills of every player on every line on a skill per skill basis and ranked them accordingly.

As a personal preference i left out the following skills: fighting, penalty shots, discipline and durability

Here is Gordie's Strength Meter:

1. Stampede

Buffalo (score: 10802)

Line 1: 3780 (rank: 2)
Dermot Lavelle (794) | Tatu Makela (774) | Kevin Hamilton (751) | GOD McZehrl (748) | TJ Bayley (713)
CH: 330 (rank: 3)
SK: 461 (rank: 6)
ST: 405 (rank: 11)
EN: 434 (rank: 2)
PH: 465 (rank: 4)
FO: 271 (rank: 6)
PA: 467 (rank: 1)
SC: 471 (rank: 3)
DF: 476 (rank: 6)

Line 2: 3727 (rank: 1)
Oliver Konig (778) | Alexis Metzler (767) | Viktor Marius (761) | Charles Walker (727) | Hippo Passamus (694)
CH: 265 (rank: 5)
SK: 450 (rank: 3)
ST: 428 (rank: 1)
EN: 435 (rank: 1)
PH: 463 (rank: 1)
FO: 259 (rank: 4)
PA: 464 (rank: 1)
SC: 468 (rank: 1)
DF: 495 (rank: 1)

Line 3: 3295 (rank: 3)
Brock Becker (714) | Conor McGregor (688) | Leafer Rielly (687) | Quick Mafs (622) | Samuel Jalopski (584)
CH: 222 (rank: 11)
SK: 411 (rank: 4)
ST: 339 (rank: 9)
EN: 347 (rank: 7)
PH: 432 (rank: 2)
FO: 269 (rank: 2)
PA: 424 (rank: 1)
SC: 394 (rank: 3)
DF: 457 (rank: 1)

2. Specters

New Orleans (score: 10748)

Line 1: 3716 (rank: 4)
Roman Augustus (808) | DeMaricus Smyth (783) | Piotr Czerkawski (730) | Richard Physt (720) | Adam Kaiser (675)
CH: 293 (rank: 6)
SK: 452 (rank: 8)
ST: 413 (rank: 9)
EN: 422 (rank: 7)
PH: 452 (rank: 7)
FO: 302 (rank: 1)
PA: 442 (rank: 10)
SC: 451 (rank: 7)
DF: 489 (rank: 1)

Line 2: 3694 (rank: 2)
Oisin Fletcher (807) | Joe Kurczewski (799) | Clint Eastwood (713) | Karl Hefeweizen (698) | Nicholas Williams (677)
CH: 284 (rank: 2)
SK: 453 (rank: 2)
ST: 426 (rank: 2)
EN: 416 (rank: 4)
PH: 456 (rank: 2)
FO: 284 (rank: 3)
PA: 454 (rank: 3)
SC: 435 (rank: 5)
DF: 486 (rank: 2)

Line 3: 3338 (rank: 2)
Vasily Horvat (707) | Alex Andani (706) | Xavier Paquette (674) | Sean Stevenson Jr. (641) | Patrick Brumm Jr. (610)
CH: 270 (rank: 3)
SK: 424 (rank: 1)
ST: 368 (rank: 3)
EN: 365 (rank: 4)
PH: 417 (rank: 3)
FO: 241 (rank: 10)
PA: 399 (rank: 5)
SC: 398 (rank: 2)
DF: 456 (rank: 2)

3. Blizzard

Edmonton (score: 10569)

Line 1: 3828 (rank: 1)
Hercules Rockefeller (809) | Tor Tuck (785) | Teddy Cuddles (767) | Connor Tanner (752) | Cory Knouse (715)
CH: 345 (rank: 1)
SK: 477 (rank: 1)
ST: 447 (rank: 1)
EN: 423 (rank: 4)
PH: 467 (rank: 3)
FO: 245 (rank: 13)
PA: 465 (rank: 3)
SC: 473 (rank: 1)
DF: 486 (rank: 2)

Line 2: 3579 (rank: 4)
Brady McIntyre (771) | Ensio Kalju (720) | Tony Pepperoni (719) | Jonathan Lundberg (710) | Willy Mack (659)
CH: 310 (rank: 1)
SK: 435 (rank: 5)
ST: 379 (rank: 8)
EN: 416 (rank: 5)
PH: 444 (rank: 6)
FO: 243 (rank: 9)
PA: 441 (rank: 4)
SC: 441 (rank: 4)
DF: 470 (rank: 4)

Line 3: 3162 (rank: 6)
Chippy Chiclets (686) | Derrick Glover (649) | Bernard Freeman (632) | Adam Taylor (619) | Viktor Valentine (576)
CH: 220 (rank: 12)
SK: 393 (rank: 10)
ST: 342 (rank: 8)
EN: 341 (rank: 10)
PH: 398 (rank: 6)
FO: 245 (rank: 8)
PA: 404 (rank: 3)
SC: 376 (rank: 8)
DF: 443 (rank: 3)

4. Renegades

Texas (score: 10549)

Line 1: 3689 (rank: 7)
Louie Garrett (786) | The Dude (742) | Daniel Karlsson (730) | Noah Konn (719) | Iam Essellemm (712)
CH: 292 (rank: 7)
SK: 466 (rank: 3)
ST: 420 (rank: 7)
EN: 408 (rank: 12)
PH: 454 (rank: 6)
FO: 265 (rank: 9)
PA: 433 (rank: 13)
SC: 470 (rank: 4)
DF: 481 (rank: 4)

Line 2: 3569 (rank: 5)
Liam O'Callaghan (750) | Logan Jensen (738) | Harvey Danger (700) | Colton Hagan (693) | Conklin Owen (688)
CH: 284 (rank: 3)
SK: 462 (rank: 1)
ST: 401 (rank: 4)
EN: 385 (rank: 11)
PH: 447 (rank: 5)
FO: 255 (rank: 5)
PA: 425 (rank: 8)
SC: 460 (rank: 2)
DF: 450 (rank: 12)

Line 3: 3291 (rank: 4)
Brett Kennedy (709) | Nico Gross (699) | Vladislav Konstantin (665) | Karno Gronkjaer (637) | John Grossman Jr. (581)
CH: 336 (rank: 1)
SK: 401 (rank: 7)
ST: 394 (rank: 1)
EN: 369 (rank: 3)
PH: 397 (rank: 7)
FO: 243 (rank: 9)
PA: 382 (rank: 8)
SC: 341 (rank: 12)
DF: 428 (rank: 6)

5. Panthers

Los Angeles (score: 10477)

Line 1: 3733 (rank: 3)
Sophia Bennett (812) | Matthew Auston (773) | Jon Toner (736) | Toivo Kosonen (708) | Joshua Woodcroft (704)
CH: 265 (rank: 11)
SK: 465 (rank: 4)
ST: 416 (rank: 8)
EN: 431 (rank: 3)
PH: 471 (rank: 2)
FO: 293 (rank: 2)
PA: 457 (rank: 5)
SC: 467 (rank: 5)
DF: 468 (rank: 10)

Line 2: 3397 (rank: 11)
Max Mauldin (706) | James Johnson (689) | Maurice Picard (681) | Philipp Winter (674) | Maximilian Wachter (647)
CH: 263 (rank: 6)
SK: 432 (rank: 8)
ST: 386 (rank: 7)
EN: 391 (rank: 9)
PH: 430 (rank: 11)
FO: 243 (rank: 11)
PA: 423 (rank: 10)
SC: 382 (rank: 16)
DF: 447 (rank: 13)

Line 3: 3347 (rank: 1)
Yuri Boyka Jr. (747) | Geoff Higgins (676) | Lightning Jones (656) | Matthew Leetch (648) | Willie Fisterbottom (620)
CH: 267 (rank: 4)
SK: 424 (rank: 2)
ST: 382 (rank: 2)
EN: 379 (rank: 1)
PH: 432 (rank: 1)
FO: 233 (rank: 13)
PA: 419 (rank: 2)
SC: 383 (rank: 6)
DF: 428 (rank: 5)

6. Stars

Toronto (score: 10399)

Line 1: 3715 (rank: 5)
Mikhail Lokitonov (795) | Finn Kruger (745) | Chris York (729) | Zander Rhys (728) | Joseph Lombardi (718)
CH: 269 (rank: 10)
SK: 450 (rank: 9)
ST: 444 (rank: 2)
EN: 422 (rank: 6)
PH: 474 (rank: 1)
FO: 249 (rank: 12)
PA: 467 (rank: 2)
SC: 472 (rank: 2)
DF: 468 (rank: 9)

Line 2: 3590 (rank: 3)
Anders Christiansen (764) | Bob Bergen (756) | Lyndis Vakarian (718) | Halfdan Thorstein (688) | Jordan Von Matt (664)
CH: 254 (rank: 8)
SK: 437 (rank: 4)
ST: 397 (rank: 6)
EN: 420 (rank: 3)
PH: 452 (rank: 3)
FO: 240 (rank: 13)
PA: 460 (rank: 2)
SC: 456 (rank: 3)
DF: 474 (rank: 3)

Line 3: 3094 (rank: 10)
Carter Manning (678) | Mercer Church (660) | Ben Turska (620) | Konstantin Voloshin (587) | Wolfhard Richter (549)
CH: 210 (rank: 16)
SK: 395 (rank: 9)
ST: 317 (rank: 12)
EN: 350 (rank: 6)
PH: 380 (rank: 12)
FO: 285 (rank: 1)
PA: 366 (rank: 12)
SC: 387 (rank: 4)
DF: 404 (rank: 13)

7. Platoon

West Kendall (score: 10211)

Line 1: 3684 (rank: 8)
Ludwig Koch Schroder (765) | Dani Forsberg (752) | Gabriel Wong (747) | Crossfit Jesus (728) | Rex Kirkby (692)
CH: 243 (rank: 14)
SK: 474 (rank: 2)
ST: 421 (rank: 6)
EN: 418 (rank: 9)
PH: 450 (rank: 8)
FO: 268 (rank: 7)
PA: 463 (rank: 4)
SC: 461 (rank: 6)
DF: 486 (rank: 3)

Line 2: 3445 (rank: 8)
Alex Light (732) | Florence Clijsters (720) | Trevor Wilson (711) | Karsten Kadinger (678) | Nat Emerson (604)
CH: 240 (rank: 13)
SK: 426 (rank: 14)
ST: 415 (rank: 3)
EN: 402 (rank: 6)
PH: 432 (rank: 10)
FO: 240 (rank: 14)
PA: 406 (rank: 12)
SC: 429 (rank: 6)
DF: 455 (rank: 8)

Line 3: 3082 (rank: 11)
Dayymo Ralchankinov (684) | Shaquille Derisraka (675) | Yuriy Starkonov (588) | Deku Izuku (569) | Ethan Ross (566)
CH: 248 (rank: 7)
SK: 416 (rank: 3)
ST: 290 (rank: 15)
EN: 314 (rank: 14)
PH: 390 (rank: 10)
FO: 269 (rank: 3)
PA: 375 (rank: 9)
SC: 370 (rank: 10)
DF: 410 (rank: 10)

8. Chiefs

Minnesota (score: 10181)

Line 1: 3702 (rank: 6)
Terrance Nova (810) | Bobby Watson (762) | Dick Skillstedt (751) | Spitfire (690) | Ti-Guy Emond (689)
CH: 326 (rank: 4)
SK: 449 (rank: 11)
ST: 426 (rank: 3)
EN: 436 (rank: 1)
PH: 463 (rank: 5)
FO: 265 (rank: 8)
PA: 450 (rank: 7)
SC: 420 (rank: 13)
DF: 467 (rank: 12)

Line 2: 3435 (rank: 9)
Eric Pelletier (740) | Noro Wozy (700) | Eero Niemi (667) | Poopity Scoop (664) | Geoff Moore (664)
CH: 242 (rank: 11)
SK: 433 (rank: 7)
ST: 361 (rank: 12)
EN: 422 (rank: 2)
PH: 434 (rank: 8)
FO: 249 (rank: 7)
PA: 430 (rank: 6)
SC: 412 (rank: 13)
DF: 452 (rank: 11)

Line 3: 3044 (rank: 13)
Derek Bohne (667) | Blabar Bananerstrom (611) | Caelan Fearghal (598) | Luisa Koller (587) | Tony Snow (581)
CH: 213 (rank: 15)
SK: 381 (rank: 12)
ST: 303 (rank: 14)
EN: 362 (rank: 5)
PH: 394 (rank: 8)
FO: 254 (rank: 5)
PA: 374 (rank: 10)
SC: 342 (rank: 11)
DF: 421 (rank: 7)

9. pride

San Francisco (score: 10175)

Line 1: 3482 (rank: 13)
Isak Odegard (742) | Charlie Schieck (702) | Dionyz Vyskoc (696) | Leshaun King (685) | Richard Metcalf Jr. (657)
CH: 217 (rank: 16)
SK: 442 (rank: 13)
ST: 371 (rank: 14)
EN: 414 (rank: 10)
PH: 444 (rank: 10)
FO: 239 (rank: 15)
PA: 437 (rank: 12)
SC: 450 (rank: 9)
DF: 468 (rank: 11)

Line 2: 3460 (rank: 7)
Jack Tanner (739) | Goku Muerto (702) | Dakota Reid (698) | Fedor Shirobokov (672) | Jeff Brogen (649)
CH: 250 (rank: 10)
SK: 435 (rank: 6)
ST: 400 (rank: 5)
EN: 402 (rank: 7)
PH: 441 (rank: 7)
FO: 243 (rank: 10)
PA: 398 (rank: 13)
SC: 423 (rank: 8)
DF: 468 (rank: 5)

Line 3: 3233 (rank: 5)
Steven Moyer (682) | Vince Reaper (670) | Ray Bork (652) | Kyler Gill (646) | Tauras Karazija (583)
CH: 217 (rank: 13)
SK: 397 (rank: 8)
ST: 362 (rank: 4)
EN: 371 (rank: 2)
PH: 400 (rank: 5)
FO: 256 (rank: 4)
PA: 402 (rank: 4)
SC: 399 (rank: 1)
DF: 429 (rank: 4)

10. Steelhawks

Hamilton (score: 10132)

Line 1: 3571 (rank: 12)
Robert Phelps (817) | Vijanupatan Singh (731) | Ben Dover (720) | Angelo Odjick (711) | Jean-Pierre Gay (592)
CH: 262 (rank: 13)
SK: 448 (rank: 12)
ST: 422 (rank: 5)
EN: 401 (rank: 13)
PH: 437 (rank: 14)
FO: 275 (rank: 4)
PA: 438 (rank: 11)
SC: 428 (rank: 11)
DF: 460 (rank: 13)

Line 2: 3505 (rank: 6)
Alexander Zajac (737) | Andrew Martin (701) | Nour Harrak (693) | Dank Boija (689) | Tig Murphy (685)
CH: 240 (rank: 12)
SK: 431 (rank: 9)
ST: 378 (rank: 9)
EN: 392 (rank: 8)
PH: 448 (rank: 4)
FO: 311 (rank: 1)
PA: 434 (rank: 5)
SC: 414 (rank: 11)
DF: 457 (rank: 7)

Line 3: 3056 (rank: 12)
Dwayne Wyder (644) | Eriks Skalbergs (631) | Zivan Zidek (613) | Donnie Dicks (613) | Vegeta Muerto (555)
CH: 227 (rank: 9)
SK: 373 (rank: 14)
ST: 336 (rank: 11)
EN: 328 (rank: 13)
PH: 394 (rank: 9)
FO: 234 (rank: 12)
PA: 369 (rank: 11)
SC: 385 (rank: 5)
DF: 410 (rank: 9)

11. Dragons

Calgary (score: 10101)

Line 1: 3653 (rank: 11)
Mike Izzy (832) | Otis B. Driftwood (742) | Hunter Jones (705) | Ostap Maksimov (698) | Nicky Pedersen Jr. (676)
CH: 317 (rank: 5)
SK: 457 (rank: 7)
ST: 378 (rank: 13)
EN: 423 (rank: 5)
PH: 441 (rank: 11)
FO: 256 (rank: 11)
PA: 455 (rank: 6)
SC: 449 (rank: 10)
DF: 477 (rank: 5)

Line 2: 3317 (rank: 13)
Shooter McGavin (703) | Casey Creller (698) | Esa Anrikkanen (672) | Rainbow Dash (662) | Chuck Goody Jr. (582)
CH: 269 (rank: 4)
SK: 430 (rank: 11)
ST: 342 (rank: 15)
EN: 380 (rank: 13)
PH: 411 (rank: 15)
FO: 230 (rank: 15)
PA: 393 (rank: 15)
SC: 407 (rank: 14)
DF: 455 (rank: 9)

Line 3: 3131 (rank: 8)
Paddy O'Sullivan (694) | Brock Nuck (643) | Mikael Choybuk (624) | Brennan Kennedy Jr. (594) | Chico Smeb (576)
CH: 245 (rank: 8)
SK: 402 (rank: 6)
ST: 313 (rank: 13)
EN: 345 (rank: 9)
PH: 388 (rank: 11)
FO: 246 (rank: 7)
PA: 392 (rank: 7)
SC: 382 (rank: 7)
DF: 418 (rank: 8)

12. Wolfpack

New England (score: 10081)

Line 1: 3664 (rank: 10)
Tigole Bitties (782) | Manuel Gotze (745) | Sami Owens (718) | Xander Green (714) | Herb Robert (705)
CH: 285 (rank: 8)
SK: 464 (rank: 5)
ST: 422 (rank: 4)
EN: 413 (rank: 11)
PH: 440 (rank: 12)
FO: 276 (rank: 3)
PA: 445 (rank: 9)
SC: 450 (rank: 8)
DF: 469 (rank: 8)

Line 2: 3427 (rank: 10)
Artemi Berezin (723) | Mattias Enqvist (710) | Rafe Ulrich (700) | Kristaps Ball (654) | Maximilian Egger (640)
CH: 235 (rank: 14)
SK: 431 (rank: 10)
ST: 361 (rank: 13)
EN: 387 (rank: 10)
PH: 419 (rank: 14)
FO: 285 (rank: 2)
PA: 423 (rank: 9)
SC: 425 (rank: 7)
DF: 461 (rank: 6)

Line 3: 2990 (rank: 14)
Cam Ouellette (631) | Jacob Geza (605) | Viatcheslav Orlov (598) | Jack Daniels (580) | Kristers Dzelme (576)
CH: 225 (rank: 10)
SK: 377 (rank: 13)
ST: 343 (rank: 7)
EN: 338 (rank: 11)
PH: 373 (rank: 14)
FO: 238 (rank: 11)
PA: 365 (rank: 14)
SC: 332 (rank: 15)
DF: 399 (rank: 14)

13. Rage

Manhattan (score: 9868)

Line 1: 3441 (rank: 14)
Reginald MacIntyre (712) | Jax Aittokallio (709) | Reginald Rove (692) | David Kastrba (673) | Tokek Takshak (655)
CH: 265 (rank: 12)
SK: 435 (rank: 14)
ST: 404 (rank: 12)
EN: 365 (rank: 15)
PH: 439 (rank: 13)
FO: 243 (rank: 14)
PA: 422 (rank: 14)
SC: 410 (rank: 16)
DF: 458 (rank: 14)

Line 2: 3327 (rank: 12)
Yannick Berger (702) | Alex Winters (682) | Luke Thomason (678) | Barret McCarthy (636) | Craig Finley (629)
CH: 217 (rank: 15)
SK: 419 (rank: 15)
ST: 355 (rank: 14)
EN: 347 (rank: 16)
PH: 434 (rank: 9)
FO: 254 (rank: 6)
PA: 426 (rank: 7)
SC: 421 (rank: 9)
DF: 454 (rank: 10)

Line 3: 3100 (rank: 9)
Sulak O'Hritea (676) | Mika Mayfield (659) | James Dekens (652) | Sachimo Zoidberg Jr. (584) | Gordie Maple (529)
CH: 251 (rank: 5)
SK: 405 (rank: 5)
ST: 355 (rank: 6)
EN: 334 (rank: 12)
PH: 378 (rank: 13)
FO: 247 (rank: 6)
PA: 365 (rank: 13)
SC: 371 (rank: 9)
DF: 394 (rank: 15)

14. syndicate

Chicago (score: 9757)

Line 1: 3311 (rank: 15)
Luke Atmey (753) | Fredrich Koenig (672) | Mikhail Petrikov (640) | Jack Kennedy (632) | Daniel Smeb (614)
CH: 223 (rank: 15)
SK: 428 (rank: 15)
ST: 358 (rank: 15)
EN: 373 (rank: 14)
PH: 426 (rank: 15)
FO: 231 (rank: 16)
PA: 409 (rank: 15)
SC: 418 (rank: 15)
DF: 445 (rank: 15)

Line 2: 3308 (rank: 15)
Sven Brokstad (696) | Mikkel Haugen (694) | Romualds Loks (678) | Kire Yelkrab (629) | Buck Maverick (611)
CH: 251 (rank: 9)
SK: 427 (rank: 13)
ST: 362 (rank: 11)
EN: 367 (rank: 15)
PH: 424 (rank: 13)
FO: 241 (rank: 12)
PA: 383 (rank: 16)
SC: 413 (rank: 12)
DF: 440 (rank: 15)

Line 3: 3138 (rank: 7)
Muhammad McLovin (655) | Svatoslav Bodnar (648) | Gvidas Kazlauskas (644) | Kyle Keenan Jr. (601) | Helmuts Akmenlauks (590)
CH: 273 (rank: 2)
SK: 387 (rank: 11)
ST: 356 (rank: 5)
EN: 345 (rank: 8)
PH: 403 (rank: 4)
FO: 231 (rank: 14)
PA: 396 (rank: 6)
SC: 340 (rank: 13)
DF: 407 (rank: 12)

15. Jets

Winnipeg (score: 9704)

Line 1: 3676 (rank: 9)
Jason Visser (807) | Gary Grease (769) | Troy McClure III (708) | Lil Manius (702) | Corey Bearss (690)
CH: 337 (rank: 2)
SK: 449 (rank: 10)
ST: 407 (rank: 10)
EN: 420 (rank: 8)
PH: 448 (rank: 9)
FO: 265 (rank: 10)
PA: 448 (rank: 8)
SC: 427 (rank: 12)
DF: 475 (rank: 7)

Line 2: 3315 (rank: 14)
Max Weber (696) | Ola Wagstrom (680) | Ignatius Blunt (667) | Ace Redding (642) | Max Poulin (630)
CH: 215 (rank: 16)
SK: 428 (rank: 12)
ST: 368 (rank: 10)
EN: 381 (rank: 12)
PH: 429 (rank: 12)
FO: 223 (rank: 16)
PA: 411 (rank: 11)
SC: 415 (rank: 10)
DF: 445 (rank: 14)

Line 3: 2713 (rank: 16)
Vladimir Vaskov (588) | Nolan Snipez (558) | Chase Byron (535) | Andrew Hawkins (519) | Cara Hohenberg (513)
CH: 215 (rank: 14)
SK: 339 (rank: 15)
ST: 277 (rank: 16)
EN: 288 (rank: 16)
PH: 352 (rank: 15)
FO: 231 (rank: 15)
PA: 354 (rank: 15)
SC: 286 (rank: 16)
DF: 371 (rank: 16)

16. Barracuda

Tampa Bay (score: 9374)

Line 1: 3298 (rank: 16)
Flacko Lagerfield (736) | Kevin Kazarian (679) | Cameron Carter II (679) | Shoyu Kikkoman (624) | Gilmore Tuttle (580)
CH: 275 (rank: 9)
SK: 424 (rank: 16)
ST: 308 (rank: 16)
EN: 345 (rank: 16)
PH: 426 (rank: 16)
FO: 274 (rank: 5)
PA: 396 (rank: 16)
SC: 419 (rank: 14)
DF: 431 (rank: 16)

Line 2: 3228 (rank: 16)
Maui (667) | Boris Denisovich (652) | Kolja Seppanen (642) | David Fantobens (637) | Blaine McElroy (630)
CH: 262 (rank: 7)
SK: 408 (rank: 16)
ST: 339 (rank: 16)
EN: 370 (rank: 14)
PH: 398 (rank: 16)
FO: 245 (rank: 8)
PA: 394 (rank: 14)
SC: 392 (rank: 15)
DF: 420 (rank: 16)

Line 3: 2848 (rank: 15)
Cash Savage (640) | Inari Twain (633) | Lillie Jacobs (596) | Michael Owens (505) | Brett Jones (474)
CH: 249 (rank: 6)
SK: 335 (rank: 16)
ST: 338 (rank: 10)
EN: 309 (rank: 15)
PH: 330 (rank: 16)
FO: 209 (rank: 16)
PA: 331 (rank: 16)
SC: 338 (rank: 14)
DF: 409 (rank: 11)

DeletedAtUserRequest · 03-22-2019, 07:15 AM

@gordieboom you have been kicking some ass with your media of late. Great work.
+1

|

|

|

GCool · 03-22-2019, 07:20 AM

I know you might just want to get paid in full, but this layout of your findings isnt very aesthetically friendly. Also to claim 3000 words when 90% of it is player names seems a little much.

It's cool, dont get me wrong, I mean I've always seen people stats on the roster page and wondered what the number was added up. I think our little data monsters could use a lesson in visualization, though.

gordieboom · 03-22-2019, 07:46 AM

03-22-2019, 07:20 AMGCool Wrote: I know you might just want to get paid in full, but this layout of your findings isnt very aesthetically friendly. Also to claim 3000 words when 90% of it is player names seems a little much.

It's cool, dont get me wrong, I mean I've always seen people stats on the roster page and wondered what the number was added up. I think our little data monsters could use a lesson in visualization, though.

Thanks for the feedback. I’ll leave the grading to the grading people and removed the word count Wink

Not sure how i could present it more aesthetically. I am open for taking a lesson.

trella · 03-22-2019, 07:47 AM

03-22-2019, 07:20 AMGCool Wrote: I know you might just want to get paid in full, but this layout of your findings isnt very aesthetically friendly. Also to claim 3000 words when 90% of it is player names seems a little much.

It's cool, dont get me wrong, I mean I've always seen people stats on the roster page and wondered what the number was added up. I think our little data monsters could use a lesson in visualization, though.

@luketd does it with every article and it doesn’t seem to be a problem, what’s the difference

ily luke

Thanks to @karey and @JSS for the sigs!

Former USA Fed Head, Carolina Kraken Co-GM, Tampa Bay Barracuda GM

GCool · 03-22-2019, 08:18 AM

03-22-2019, 07:46 AMgordieboom Wrote:
03-22-2019, 07:20 AMGCool Wrote: I know you might just want to get paid in full, but this layout of your findings isnt very aesthetically friendly. Also to claim 3000 words when 90% of it is player names seems a little much.

It's cool, dont get me wrong, I mean I've always seen people stats on the roster page and wondered what the number was added up. I think our little data monsters could use a lesson in visualization, though.

Thanks for the feedback. I’ll leave the grading to the grading people and removed the word count

Not sure how i could present it more aesthetically. I am open for taking a lesson.

It's not publishing the word count that bugs me. It's inflating it by just copying rows of your Excel data.

Just put it in a table, at the very least. That's all I'm saying. But thanks for listening / accepting my criticism. I don't mean to be a prick - most of the time. Smile

GCool · 03-22-2019, 08:20 AM

03-22-2019, 07:47 AMcpetrella Wrote:
03-22-2019, 07:20 AMGCool Wrote: I know you might just want to get paid in full, but this layout of your findings isnt very aesthetically friendly. Also to claim 3000 words when 90% of it is player names seems a little much.

It's cool, dont get me wrong, I mean I've always seen people stats on the roster page and wondered what the number was added up. I think our little data monsters could use a lesson in visualization, though.

@luketd does it with every article and it doesn’t seem to be a problem, what’s the difference

ily luke

Nah, I have a problem with that, too. It's bullshit and has little reading value. It's cool stuff, but that's about it. With all of his TPE ranking threads being a circle jerk, why would I post a critical reply in there? It would just get lost.

gordieboom · 03-22-2019, 08:31 AM

03-22-2019, 08:18 AMGCool Wrote:
03-22-2019, 07:46 AMgordieboom Wrote: Thanks for the feedback. I’ll leave the grading to the grading people and removed the word count

Not sure how i could present it more aesthetically. I am open for taking a lesson.

It's not publishing the word count that bugs me. It's inflating it by just copying rows of your Excel data.

Just put it in a table, at the very least. That's all I'm saying. But thanks for listening / accepting my criticism. I don't mean to be a prick - most of the time.

Yeah table would be nice, but the table html tag is not supported on this forum or i am overlooking it.

GCool · 03-22-2019, 08:46 AM

Here's my attempt @gordieboom . This was just a cursory glance at what you had provided. You could break it down by position, best player on each line, etc ... I'm sure you have the Excel data since that's probably how you copied it down. But doing things like conditional formatting and normalization make it look a little cooler while giving you a window to actually explain your findings more thoroughly:

[Image: o16vFLm.png]

Does that make sense? I hardly want to be perceived as "all talk" - I like the work some of you guys are doing, it's just an eyesore sometimes when I want to actually read something cool or understand the creator's reasoning and gist of the data in the first place. Creating numbers is easy when you have a simulator! Interpretation is what deserves bonus fake money.

Edit: Noticed a sorting mistake my formula on the last table made. Seems like a few teams went up in rank when you normalize it - interesting! Wink

***WannabeFinn*** · 03-22-2019, 08:52 AM

I like this because Buffalo gud

Mayuu · 03-22-2019, 09:00 AM

I like this sort of stats rather then reading about "Firstname Lastnames adventure in the San Fransico public bathrooms"

I'd prefer this over 90% over all other articles.

RETIRED

Keygan · 03-22-2019, 09:48 AM

All I’m seeing is TBB is bad.

jRuutu · 03-22-2019, 09:52 AM

Edmonton truly a goon unit! Blizzard

trella · 03-22-2019, 09:56 AM

03-22-2019, 08:20 AMGCool Wrote:
03-22-2019, 07:47 AMcpetrella Wrote: @luketd does it with every article and it doesn’t seem to be a problem, what’s the difference

ily luke

Nah, I have a problem with that, too. It's bullshit and has little reading value. It's cool stuff, but that's about it. With all of his TPE ranking threads being a circle jerk, why would I post a critical reply in there? It would just get lost.

So you come and critique a new user’s post thats just trying to make money and is just starting out on the site? I don’t see the logic in that. Wouldn’t you want more people to see the issues? Commenting this on Luke’s medias would be much more practical if thats what you want.

Also, who wants to get paid maybe 600k for a bunch of work? These statistical things are not easy to set up like god forbid users get paid for it.

Thanks to @karey and @JSS for the sigs!

Former USA Fed Head, Carolina Kraken Co-GM, Tampa Bay Barracuda GM

Sami · 03-22-2019, 09:58 AM

03-22-2019, 09:56 AMcpetrella Wrote:
03-22-2019, 08:20 AMGCool Wrote: Nah, I have a problem with that, too. It's bullshit and has little reading value. It's cool stuff, but that's about it. With all of his TPE ranking threads being a circle jerk, why would I post a critical reply in there? It would just get lost.

So you come and critique a new user’s post thats just trying to make money and is just starting out on the site? I don’t see the logic in that. Wouldn’t you want more people to see the issues? Commenting this on Luke’s medias would be much more practical if thats what you want.

Also, who wants to get paid maybe 600k for a bunch of work? These statistical things are not easy to set up like god forbid users get paid for it.

This.

Navigation

Extra Menu

About us