04-23-2025, 01:19 PMsköldpaddor Wrote: I mean ACKSHULLY, isn't it a budget related thing though? Isn't keeping a player on your roster who you haven't paid or signed budget related?

04-23-2025, 01:28 PMhockeyiscool Wrote: Sorry I haven't slept yet so my brain isn't functioning at 100% so I'm missing words and points. I don't like budget penalties in general, because of how they impact the allure of a replacement GM that usually ends up cleaning the mess up of the person who violates the rules that then leave the site paired with them also displacing a player on the existing roster and respecting players wishes of where they want to play is kind of a cornerstone of the league. At least it has been for me, If a ruling prevented me from playing on a team that I want to play for, I would probably just quit the league.

04-23-2025, 10:04 AMsköldpaddor Wrote: I do think you're right that it wouldn't have mattered in the end functionally if the player was crashered or not. It's clear he wanted to go back to his team, he could have just signed after the freeze. The big issue here is that the movement requirement wasn't fulfilled, and the player played without a contract.

When we asked the team about this, the response wasn't "oh he's crashered' it was "we forgot to sign him" and then later after we had explained the consequences of both not signing and not moving, the "loophole" of "he was crashered" was brought up after the fact. At no point were we given the impression that the team actually believed the contract was a done deal at the time of crashering, it was fully acknowledged that the signing had been overlooked.

Again, we all feel pretty icky about players not being able to play for the teams they want to play for. But we also feel icky about people getting away with not following the rules while other people are following those rules. We just want this process to be as easy as possible for everybody, and that requires cooperation from everybody. Also, as I've stated earlier in the thread, I am so, so open to suggestions for any other kind of consequence for this rule that will actually work, and doesn't screw over the entire team just as hard as this screws over one singular player. A cap fine would likely mean some other player would have to leave the team against their will (unless the team in question is rolling in extra cap space), we can always remove picks but there are only so many picks you can remove, and that doesn't leave us much wiggle room for the cases where a team neglects to move more than one player. (Like, say a team doesn't move four of their players. Do we fine them four picks for that? Or do we just make a flat price where if you miss one you might as well miss them all?)

04-23-2025, 10:54 AMHallsy Wrote: And sometimes mistakes happen and like it sucks but life is tough sometimes for everyone. Idk I just see some of these rules of people power tripping and just like I don't see any malicious intent or anything here so why is there a punishment and not just a warning of some sort.

04-23-2025, 01:28 PMhockeyiscool Wrote: Sorry I haven't slept yet so my brain isn't functioning at 100% so I'm missing words and points.

04-23-2025, 01:52 PMDrokeep Wrote: Reminder that the forge won s69

04-23-2025, 02:02 PMCementHands Wrote: Yea, like sometimes you accidentally find an exploit in the sim engine, forget to report it because your phone died, then regress all of your players to fit the exploit, and then run through the rest of the league like a warm knife through butter.
It was a really fun moment for the rest of the league.

04-23-2025, 02:02 PMCementHands Wrote: Yea, like sometimes you accidentally find an exploit in the sim engine, forget to report it because your phone died, then regress all of your players to fit the exploit, and then run through the rest of the league like a warm knife through butter.
It was a really fun moment for the rest of the league.

04-23-2025, 02:02 PMCementHands Wrote: Yea, like sometimes you accidentally find an exploit in the sim engine, forget to report it because your phone died, then regress all of your players to fit the exploit, and then run through the rest of the league like a warm knife through butter.
It was a really fun moment for the rest of the league.

04-23-2025, 02:12 PMCount Chocula Wrote: 4 teams made mistakes and now they suffer the consequences, that's how it goes. Now hopefully they won't make similar mistakes in the future and all the other 16 teams can feel good about doing it by the book.

On the other topic, I don't agree with HO locking threads. You should 100% be able to go spend time with your family and not worry about this league at all. However if HO feels like they can't step away for a few hours without this place burning to the ground, then what are we even doing here? If the community is that toxic maybe we should just pull the plug. However I believe there are enough rational, good natured people here to inter regulate. If anyone crosses a line just punish them whenever someone gets back.

04-23-2025, 02:02 PMCementHands Wrote: Yea, like sometimes you accidentally find an exploit in the sim engine, forget to report it because your phone died, then regress all of your players to fit the exploit, and then run through the rest of the league like a warm knife through butter.
It was a really fun moment for the rest of the league.

04-23-2025, 02:14 PMAephino Wrote: just popping in to mark some territory in case this gets locked with the appeal thread up