+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: Community (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Forum: SHL Discussion (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=49)
+---- Forum: Suggestion Box (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=50)
+---- Thread: Unretirement (/showthread.php?tid=8764)
- Abdeezy - 06-09-2012
I would just oblidge a certain amount of seasons with one player until you can un-retire. Something like 4-6 seasons.
- BasedMinkus - 06-09-2012
If your player was a legit top star, they should be able to unretire (i.e. Lemieux, Forsberg, and now maybe hasek)
- LX_Theo - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by LX_Theo@Jun 9 2012, 05:58 PMAdding onto this... If you want to do a committee to pick each individual penalty, that would work.
Maybe not BAN it.... But put a HUGE penalty TPE wise on any player unretiring.
- Otrebor13 - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by JayTee@Jun 9 2012, 07:30 PM
If your player was a legit top star, they should be able to unretire (i.e. Lemieux, Forsberg, and now maybe hasek)
However, the player should come back with a penalty. Lemieux, Forsberg, etc. didn't come back as dominant as they were. They regressed with age, and SHLers should pay the same price.
You're proposing this because Karpo was a star, but Karpo has been retired for what, 3 seasons now? There should be no way a guy that's need retired that long should be able to come back and be as dominant as he was
- BasedMinkus - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Otrebor13@Jun 9 2012, 04:34 PM
However, the player should come back with a penalty. Lemieux, Forsberg, etc. didn't come back as dominant as they were. They regressed with age, and SHLers should pay the same price.
You're proposing this because Karpo was a star, but Karpo has been retired for what, 3 seasons now? There should be no way a guy that's need retired that long should be able to come back and be as dominant as he was
yea i think it should be something like you take your TPE and take off 10% or something.
Also Lemieux was dominant for the first few seasons back
- teztify - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by OcAirlines@Jun 9 2012, 07:04 PM
I wouldn't ban unretirement completely, but maybe we should implement some kind of penalty for the unretired player. For example, for every year he was gone he lost 10% of his total TPE or something like that. The years a player wasn't active should also count against his regression-timer (if they don't already do).
But also make it so they have to fulfill their Entry Level Contract with their new player first.
- Otrebor13 - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by JayTee@Jun 9 2012, 07:38 PM
yea i think it should be something like you take your TPE and take off 10% or something.
Also Lemieux was dominant for the first few seasons back
I think it should be penalized depending on seasons not active, rather than as a whole. Because if someone is retired for, say, 2 seasons and another guy for 5, why should they be penalized equally?
- BasedMinkus - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Otrebor13@Jun 9 2012, 04:39 PM
I think it should be penalized depending on seasons not active, rather than as a whole. Because if someone is retired for, say, 2 seasons and another guy for 5, why should they be penalized equally?
yee i agree, but do u take eel into account with that
- RomanesEuntDomus - 06-09-2012
I think it wouldn't be too hard to find a scale for that, something along the lines of:
Retired for...
1 Season: 10% TPE loss
2 Seasons: 20%
3 Seasons: 25%
4 Seasons: 30%
5 Seasons: 35%
Longer than 5 Seasons: Unretirement not possible
- Spangle - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by OcAirlines@Jun 9 2012, 08:52 PM
I think it wouldn't be too hard to find a scale for that, something along the lines of:
Retired for...
1 Season: 10% TPE loss
2 Seasons: 20%
3 Season: 25%
4 Seasons: 30%
5 Seasons: 35%
Longer than 5 Seasons: Unretirement not possible
I also like the mention above about seeing out your ELC. That's a good one.
- stud - 06-09-2012
LIke I have suggested, make them regress...
http://theshl.b1.jcink.com/index.php?showtopic=6895&st=0
- DangleSnipeCelly - 06-09-2012
why don't you make every unreitred player retire for good and make them take their old player back if its that big of a deal
- Spangle - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by DangleSnipeCelly@Jun 9 2012, 09:21 PM
why don't you make every unreitred player retire for good and make them take their old player back if its that big of a deal
I can't *ptthhh* understand *ptthhh* your accent. *ptthhh*
- DangleSnipeCelly - 06-09-2012
thanks spangle
- Shutout - 06-09-2012
Quote:Originally posted by Spangle@Jun 9 2012, 09:25 PM
I can't *ptthhh* understand *ptthhh* your accent. *ptthhh*
5 game suspension tbhimo.