+- Simulation Hockey League (https://simulationhockey.com)
+-- Forum: League Media (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=610)
+--- Forum: SHL Media (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=46)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (https://simulationhockey.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=545)
+---- Thread: Top 100 SHL Players of Today! (/showthread.php?tid=52560)
- Lunaro - 07-11-2015
rofl. experts were a joke this year. career year on a cup finalist team and they drop me down 2? And they had nothing to back up their rating other than "attitude problems?" rofl
- ArGarBarGar - 07-11-2015
Quote:Originally posted by Lunaro@Jul 11 2015, 09:54 PMI made that up. It's not like the experts actually put in their two cents for each of their ratings.
rofl. experts were a joke this year. career year on a cup finalist team and they drop me down 2? And they had nothing to back up their rating other than "attitude problems?" rofl
For those of you guys who are annoyed by the ratings this year: look how many people voted. That is four guys with a rating of 1-5 for each player. One down rating could drop you down a ton of spots.
- Yousuf - 07-11-2015
I'm too old to play?
- Kesler17 - 07-11-2015
Quote:Originally posted by Wasty@Jul 11 2015, 03:32 PMsame
Hmmm.. either in the Top 30 or fallen off completely haha.
- Mac - 07-11-2015
Few things people are seeming to forget. Holding steady is not a bad thing, large drops are due to new players emerging and small rises if any will likely hold steady next season.
A lot of Season 20-21 players made the list as new members and were ranked quite high, causing some of the past top 25 to drop a bit from the looks of it.
List is definitely a little weird this year though.
- Kel - 07-11-2015
Quote:Originally posted by ArGarBarGar@Jul 11 2015, 09:57 PMMake the ratings out of 10, so the final rankings are more accurate.
I made that up. It's not like the experts actually put in their two cents for each of their ratings.
For those of you guys who are annoyed by the ratings this year: look how many people voted. That is four guys with a rating of 1-5 for each player. One down rating could drop you down a ton of spots.
- Ace - 07-11-2015
scrublords that write for this list
- ArGarBarGar - 07-11-2015
Quote:Originally posted by Ace@Jul 11 2015, 10:31 PMThanks.
scrublords that write for this list
- Mac - 07-11-2015
Quote:Originally posted by Ace@Jul 12 2015, 12:31 AM
scrublords that write for this list
Yep, defensive defensemen are totally unappreciated in this league. They could create trophies for that sort of thing like they have the Dar for forwards. But it seems unless you put up those nice shiny points, no one wants to give a 4-5 it (I gave one of those two for certain) because stopping goals at least for me is just as valued as putting them in.
Maybe the league will do this this season?
- ArGarBarGar - 07-11-2015
Quote:Originally posted by Mac@Jul 11 2015, 10:46 PMThere isn't a stat which definitively measures defensive play.
Yep, defensive defensemen are totally unappreciated in this league. They could create trophies for that sort of thing like they have the Dar for forwards. But it seems unless you put up those nice shiny points, no one wants to give a 4-5 it (I gave one of those two for certain) because stopping goals at least for me is just as valued as putting them in.
Maybe the league will do this this season?
Hitting an +/- aren't that at all, unless that is just what we equate with defensive play in this league.
- Mac - 07-12-2015
Quote:Originally posted by ArGarBarGar@Jul 12 2015, 12:49 AM
There isn't a stat which definitively measures defensive play.
Hitting an +/- aren't that at all, unless that is just what we equate with defensive play in this league.
Shots blocked, hits taken, plus minus and hitting since takeaways are gone :(
Damn you SIMON!!!
- GroupMeIsKindOfOkay - 07-12-2015
Quote:Originally posted by Mac@Jul 11 2015, 11:03 PMhits taken doesn't measure defensive play
Shots blocked, hits taken, plus minus and hitting since takeaways are gone :(
Damn you SIMON!!!
)
- 701 aka YUNG GUAP GOD - 07-12-2015
)This list tho
- Blues - 07-12-2015
Beat Mook :->
- Ballerstorm - 07-12-2015
Quote:Originally posted by Shevy Shev@Jul 11 2015, 11:24 PMIs hits taken how many times you get hit and lose the puck or how many hits you absorb while being able to keep the puck
hits taken doesn't measure defensive play