04-23-2025, 12:26 PMSymmetrik Wrote: I do think that in the case of a different player having to move it's better overall, someone who wasn't involved might have to go but ultimately that's a consequence and a decision for the GM to make, and they might do their best by their players in rectifying their own mistake. Plus, trades would likely include roster players moving, which means everyone stays on a team. At this point Sizz and 2 others are still FAs and it's less than 3 hours until the sim, so they will likely miss out on games because of this too. I think a punishment that impacts the whole team is fair because the GM impacts the whole team. And the GM is left to sort out the consequences of their own mistakes. If a player is traded to take the fall for a GM's mistake then so be it, but at least that decision is a personal choice made by the GM. Hell, maybe in order to protect their team they retire their own player and trade them away.

Also I'd say it's scalable if you adjust it to the value of the contracts. Sizz's minimum is 5 million. If there was a 2nd player with a minimum of 3 million, then the penalty can be 8 million. So on and so forth.

Oh interesting, I actually kinda do like the idea of cap penalty that adjusts by the player's contract/TPE level, I don't think that's one we've discussed yet, let me take that back to the math nerds in the room!