Quote:Originally posted by Maxy@Sep 21 2013, 06:55 PM

Not really anything due to scouting. Out of all my draft picks they've all turned out quite well and most trades I've made have been very even for both teams and benefited both teams equally. As far as drafting goes I've drafted 2 players who were SHL Gm's within the past season, both of which were moved due to that fact that they wanted the chance to GM. I'm not making a claim to be the most successful GM as I haven't proved that yet but also take into account that I've had 2 rebuilds abruptly ended short due to moving a player for their betterment setting me back. One thing I can say I feel I've done extremely well is trading, drafting and treating my players fairly and while it hasn't necessarily worked out on the record sheet yet. it's not due to lack of effort or skill. More due to extenuating circumstances beyond my control, and while yes I suppose I could have been selfish and neglected to give players like Toast, Velevra, HFFO the chances they were looking for (As I had no real obligation to do so seeing as they were all under contract for at least 2 more seasons at the time I let them have their chance) I had their best interests in mind. So no I don't see anyone who hasn't played for me to argue I'm anything higher than 10-12, but honestly I think you'd be hard pressed to find a player who has played for me that would downplay my skills as GM.

I understand the Player GM type thing. You can ask anyone who played for me in my 5 seasons as GM the same thing, I was always fair, and always had their best interests in mind. People would ask to be traded to certain teams, without a NTC, I would comply because the league is about being enjoyable. People wanted to try a different position or more playing time, I'd give them a chance.

However, that didn't make me a top 3 GM.

I understand the him ranking you as his favourite GM.

Your skills are measured by how well you do. You can compare it to those guys in the NHL who go top 5 and never amount to anything. Sure they are skilled, but it's putting it together that makes you good.