Make player max or not to make player max on their career?

There has been discussions if it's better to max out players in their career to not at all. To me, it's simple. If players do not max out, it creates more player builds around the league. It creates more motivation of improvement. I don't care if you decrease the starting cap for players to 25, 15, or even 5 and have a cap at around 70 but a league with few elite players at 90 SC, 80 PA, 90 skating is better than a league with a lot elite players at 99 SC, 99 PA, 99 SK, 99 DF.

A player maxing out at 99 everything should have had done a major accomplishment to do so. It should be a very big challenge that only a few could pull off. It should be that at the end of the day, you look back and say "dang, that guy is such a try hard no lifer to even have done that."