A hall of fame player should have individual and team accolades. If he doesn't have any Cups, people should recognize him as a perennial Stevens candidate, for example, at the very least. Bottom line, fans of the game shouldn't say "uh, who?" upon hearing an inductees name. They should play the position well and have numbers or awards to back it up.

Also color me shocked that McZ breaks his post drought jn a thread that says "HOF"