Create Account

TBB Illegal Roster Appeal
#1
(This post was last modified: 04-24-2025, 09:40 AM by DrunkenTeddy. Edited 3 times in total.)

Hello SHL,

The Appeals Commitee has received an appeal regarding this punishment: https://simulationhockey.com/showthread.php?tid=142654.

In this particular case the player Max Carnage had agreed to a contract with TBB prior to the deadline and the current rulebook regulation states that the DM agreement is considered a completed contract:

Code:
Section 1 Subsection K Rule 1 states: A contract agreed to by a player and GM is enforceable even if it was made through DMs or on Discord. Players and GMs may not back out of a negotiated deal once it has been agreed to. The contract is considered complete at the time of agreement, not the time of the of posting on the site.

Head Office did update this process through a discord messages to the GMs, but the committee agrees that the rulebook should be considered the source of truth in cases of conflict. Max Carnage (@Sizz) is considered to have an agreed contract with the team and is no longer considered a FA.

The other punishments as follows are for the missed GM tasks and not having a valid signing of Shawn Pawn. These punishments remain in affect:
Tampa Bay’s GM’s @hockeyiscool and @EmoLeBron will be fined half of their GM salary in S82.
Tampa Bay will forfeit their S84 2nd round pick.

[Image: DrunkenTeddy.gif]




[Image: Tqabyfh.png]  |  [Image: sXDU6JX.png]
Reply
#2

[Image: 4]

[Image: Caleb_H.gif]
Reply
#3

swedish chef cooked here

[Image: hw6Eojc.png]

[Image: lqfXIpe.jpeg]
Reply
#4

thank you appeals, absolutely no disagreement on this one <3

[Image: gunnarsoderberg.gif]



[Image: DG0jZcS.png]
. : [Image: U66t7Jy.png] : .
Reply
#5

Wow I made it on the first page
Reply
#6

@sytarah thoughts on this outcome

[Image: Gabe-lights.png]
[Image: nMz40Vc.gif]

Reply
#7

Holding the rulebook as the sole determining basis of the rules and their interpretation is definitely a very solid choice. That'll make everything easier on everyone

[Image: 59269_s.gif]





S66 Damian Littleton

[Image: kILVP74.png]
Reply
#8

Accept

[Image: oknomSHL.gif]
Reply
#9

yes chef

[Image: gLIi4AC.png]
[Image: beegbeegyoshi.gif]
Reply
#10

Thank you for a reasonable and decent outcome. If unwritten rules are the new bar for punishment then let's just punish everyone. It feels good to know there are still people we can trust up there.

[Image: qm0v49d.png]
Reply
#11

04-23-2025, 01:53 PMtaterswc Wrote: Thank you for a reasonable and decent outcome. If unwritten rules are the new bar for punishment then let's just punish everyone. It feels good to know there are still people we can trust up there.

This seems a little disingenuous given that the rule wasn't "unwritten" it was clearly communicated to GMs multiple times and acknowledged by the GM in question, it just had not been added to the rulebook yet.

I'm personally totally satisfied with the outcome of this one, but to imply that all of Head Office is not "trustworthy" for following through on procedures that were clearly communicated to GMs in multiple places seems...rough.

[Image: gunnarsoderberg.gif]



[Image: DG0jZcS.png]
. : [Image: U66t7Jy.png] : .
Reply
#12

04-23-2025, 01:46 PMGwdjohnson Wrote: @sytarah thoughts on this outcome
any% thread lock speedrun
Reply
#13

This is a massive HO and Appeals Committee W. The SHL wins as a league today. Thank you all for coming to my TED talk

[Image: AgentSmith630.gif]
Thanks to @sulovilen, @the5urreal, and @sve7en for the sigs!
[Image: mf7ERAf.png]
Reply
#14

ho L. cant read the rule book #clearly
Reply
#15

Whats the punishment for not updating the rulebook until past the deadline

Reply




Users browsing this thread:
1 Guest(s)




Navigation

 

Extra Menu

 

About us

The Simulation Hockey League is a free online forums based sim league where you create your own fantasy hockey player. Join today and create your player, become a GM, get drafted, sign contracts, make trades and compete against hundreds of players from around the world.